Wiki: ReMix Changelog

Revision as of 20:33, 11 May 2011 by Liontamer (talk | contribs)

Previously approved tracks may be removed from OC ReMix for a number of reasons:

  • if it is determined to be 'stolen'
  • primarily or entirely not created by the submitting artist
  • directly sampling the game audio, a.k.a. 'ripping,' with minimal original contributions (e.g. a few breakbeats layered on top)
  • based off a MIDI arrangement, a.k.a. 'MIDI ripping,' with only instruments changed (no original notes)
  • if it fails to meet several of the other submission standards pertaining to originality and content
  • at the request of the ReMixer

ReMixes recalled by djpretzel or Judges Panel vote due to submission standards exceptions

  • Bart Klepka - Alone in the Dark 2 'Hell's Kitchen (Zombies & Thompsons Mix)'
  • Reason: currently unknown
  • Bart Klepka - Darklands 'L'homme Arme (Guided by Saints Mix)'
  • Reason: currently unknown
  • Bart Klepka - Duke Nukem 3D 'Gotham (Distorted Mix)'
  • Reason: currently unknown
  • Bart Klepka - Dune 'Sietch to Sietch (Sekence Mix)'
  • Reason: currently unknown
  • DarkCecil13 - Final Fantasy Mystic Quest 'DC13 Mystic Quest'
  • Reason: Stolen arrangement from Final Fantasy USA: Mystic Quest Sound Collections album.
  • DJ Frog - Chrono Trigger 'Millenial Fair Bad Tuna'
  • Reason: SPC rip + drums.
  • DJ Seith - Super Mario World 'Flat Goom Beat'
  • Reason: Directly samples most of Mr. Oiso's "Flat Beat".
  • djpretzel - Galaxy Force II 'Nominal'
  • Reason: MIDI rip (self-removed: long time ago!!).
  • FFmusic Dj - Final Fantasy VII 'Adelante (Mako Reactor)'
  • Reason: Primarily not created by the submitting artist.
  • unknown artist - OutRun 'Splash Wave'
  • Reason: IT rip.
  • OCR00104 - Secret of Mana 'Fear of the Heavens Flow'
  • Reason: SPC rip + drums.
  • OCR01051 - Final Fantasy IV 'Chocobo (Strings and Winds)'
  • Reason: Cover of Shirou Satou's "Chocobo-Chocobo" arrangement from Final Fantasy IV Piano Collections.
  • OCR01142 - Secret of Mana 'Mystic Invasion'
  • Reason: Too similar to the original.
  • OCR01213 - Xenogears 'Child of the Stars'
  • Reason: Too similar to the original.
  • OCR01551 - Castlevania II 'Tears of Blood'
  • Reason: "Bloody Tears," stolen from Perfect Selection Dracula Battle arrangement album.

Pre-OCR01000 Removal Process (Lockdown 1)

Prior to the posting of OCR01000, a sitewide review of everything posted to date was performed, with suggestions accepted from listeners and reviewed by the judges panel for both standards violations and quality issues, with a stronger emphasis on the former. Due to the quantity of removals, they are listed here not by category of the reason they were removed, but as a group.

Decision thread

  1. OCR00020 - Super Mario Land 'Millennium'
    • Reason: GBS rip with creative processing and drums.
  2. OCR00024 - Secret of Mana 'Fear of Heaven'
    • Reason: SPC rip + drums, author admits to it essentially being so.
  3. OCR00027 - Doom 'E1M1'
    • Reason: MIDI rip with instruments changed.
  4. OCR00031 - Sonic the Hedgehog 'Labyrinth Zone'
    • Reason: GYM rip.
  5. OCR00033 - ChuChu Rocket! 'Dale North'
    • Reason: Not a game music arrangement. Original + drums. Commercial music, not in game.
  6. OCR00039 - ChuChu Rocket! 'Bad CD'
    • Reason: Not a game music arrangement. Original + drums. Commercial music, not in game.
  7. OCR00049 - Mega Man 3 'Top Man Chuck M'
    • Reason: MIDI rip + beats.
  8. OCR00051 - Star Fox 'Space Trip'
    • Reason: Not an arrangement. Just weird sound effects, no game music.
  9. OCR00074 - Mega Man 'Vejita CutMan'
    • Reason: NSF rip + drums.
  10. OCR00075 - Final Fantasy VII 'Still More Fighting'
    • Reason: MIDI rip. Too similar to original.
  11. OCR00106 - SimCity 'Speed Town'
    • Reason: SPC rip + drums.
  12. OCR00114 - Super Metroid 'Fashion Techno'
    • Reason: Not an arrangement. Just weird sound effects, no game music.
  13. OCR00121 - Super Mario Bros. 2 'Phazeremix Rag'
    • Reason: Too similar to original. We still love McVaffe, tho.
  14. OCR00128 - Chrono Trigger 'Synthetic Time Parasite'
    • Reason: Quality issues.
  15. OCR00142 - Mega Man 2 'Weapon Gain'
    • Reason: NSF rip + drums.
  16. OCR00144 - Mega Man 2 'Trance Reality'
    • Reason: NSF rip + drums.
  17. OCR00185 - Final Fantasy VII 'One-Winged Techno'
    • Reason: MIDI rip + in-game vocals.
  18. OCR00236 - StarCraft 'Easily Amused'
    • Reason: Sound effects, no game music.
  19. OCR00242 - StarTropics 'Leaf Vibe'
    • Reason: Inspired by game. Not from any identifiable in-game music.
  20. OCR00272 - Quake III 'Thalk'
    • Reason: Mostly sound effects.
  21. OCR00281 - Kirby Super Star 'Wind Breaker'
    • Reason: SPC rip + layered scratching/fx.
  22. OCR00297 - Chrono Cross 'Open It Up'
    • Reason: WAV rip + drums, sped up.
  23. OCR00306 - Counterstrike 'Palerider Training'
    • Reason: Original/non-VGM composition + in-game voices. Game had no music.
  24. OCR00315 - Koudelka 'Requiem (Electric Flames Mix)'
    • Reason: Samples too extensively from original.
  25. OCR00679 - Counterstrike 'In the Line of Fire'
    • Reason: Original/non-VGM composition + in-game voices. Game had no music.

OCR01001–OCR01250 Removal Process (Lockdown)

Prior to the posting of OCR01250, a review of everything posted from OCR01001 to OCR01250 was performed, with suggestions proposed and reviewed by the judges panel for standards violations.

Decision thread

  1. OCR01046 - Die Hard Trilogy 'I Love the Airport'
    • Reason: Too similar to the original.
  2. OCR01051 - Ys 'Beat of Terror'
    • Reason: NSF rip. Too similar to the original.
  3. OCR01070 - Command & Conquer: Tiberian Sun 'PharoTeknical'
    • Reason: WAV rip + drums. Too similar to the original.
  4. OCR01090 - Streets of Rage 2 'Funkdreamer'
    • Reason: GYM rip. Too similar to the original.
  5. OCR01101 - Donkey Kong Country 'Strolling the Mines'
    • Reason: Usage of source instrumentation and writing (though not the original audio) is verbatim, surrounded by original/non-VGM composition.
  6. OCR01193 - F-Zero GX 'Dr. Stuard (Jeff & Toad Air Team Challengers)'
    • Reason: Too similar to the original.

Pre-OCR01500 Removal Process (Lockdown 2)

Prior to the posting of OCR01500, a second sitewide review of everything posted to date was performed, with suggestions proposed and reviewed by the judges panel for both standards violations and quality issues, with a stronger emphasis on the former. Due to the quantity of removals, they are listed here not by category of the reason they were removed, but as a group.

  1. OCR00016 - Bubble Bobble 'Jungle'
    • Reason: NSF rip + drums.
  2. OCR00017 - Bubble Bobble 'Speed Garage'
    • Reason: NSF rip + drums.
  3. OCR00018 - Mega Man 2 'Distraught'
    • Reason: NSF rip + drums.
  4. OCR00023 - Metroid 'Brinstar Theme (Ben Lewis Mix)'
    • Reason: Mostly NSF rip + drums.
  5. OCR00025 - Mega Man 'Raveland'
    • Reason: NSF rip + drums (eventually).
  6. OCR00032 - Legend of Zelda 64: Ocarina of Time 'Ocarina Boogie'
    • Reason: Original/non-VGM composition + in-game ocarina instrument as lead. Not from any identifiable in-game music.
  7. OCR00036 - Lord of the Sword 'There Can Be Only One'
    • Reason: MIDI rip. Same timing.
  8. OCR00043 - Tetris 'New Melody Mix'
    • Reason: MIDI rip of previously arranged material.
  9. OCR00047 - Mega Man 2 'Dr Asuul'
    • Reason: NSF rip + drums.
  10. OCR00052 - Golgo 13 'Duke Togo X Mix'
    • Reason: MIDI rip + Quality issues.
  11. OCR00056 - Bust-a-Groove 'Blue Knife (SignofZeta Dub)'
    • Reason: Cut up WAV rip + drums.
  12. OCR00057 - Castlevania: Symphony of the Night 'The Black Disc Mix'
    • Reason: Original/non-VGM composition with 1 in-game voice sample, author admits to it being so.
  13. OCR00069 - Metroid 'Bluebase Incidental'
    • Reason: MIDI rip + rain SFX.
  14. OCR00070 - Ghouls 'N Ghosts 'Level 5 Atomic'
    • Reason: MIDI rip.
  15. OCR00079 - Bubble Bobble 'Bubble Techno'
    • Reason: NSF rip + drums.
  16. OCR00086 - Galaga 'Galagzee'
    • Reason: Sped up WAV rips + drums.
  17. OCR00091 - Sailor Moon 'S and M Ravebody'
    • Reason: Not a game music arrangement. Music originally from anime.
  18. OCR00092 - Diablo II 'Wanderer (Flayer Mix)'
    • Reason: First portion too reliant on directly sampling the original. Second portion not from any identifiable in-game music.
  19. OCR00097 - Sonic the Hedgehog 'Water Warning'
    • Reason: Too reliant on directly sampling (and cutting up) the original.
  20. OCR00099 - Guardian Legend 'Liquid Horsey'
    • Reason: MIDI rip + Quality issues.
  21. OCR00101 - Karnov 'Russian Jam'
    • Reason: MIDI rip of previously arranged material with minor changes/additions.
  22. OCR00103 - Super Bomberman 3 'Bomb Factory'
    • Reason: SPC rips + drums/SFX.
  23. OCR00107 - Banjo-Kazooie 'Oldskool Squarewave'
    • Reason: MIDI rip + drums.
  24. OCR00108 - Castlevania (N64) 'Tower of Ambient'
    • Reason: Too reliant on directly sampling the original.
  25. OCR00113 - Altered Beast 'Psychotic Discord'
    • Reason: MIDI rip.
  26. OCR00116 - Final Fantasy 'Progressive'
    • Reason: Quality issues.
  27. OCR00117 - EarthBound 'StArMaNn Mega-Seith'
    • Reason: SPC rips + drums.
  28. OCR00119 - Bionic Commando (C64) 'BIONIC BPM'
    • Reason: SID rip + drums.
  29. OCR00125 - Sonic CD 'Da Boom'
    • Reason: WAV rip + new synths on top.
  30. OCR00131 - Diablo 'The Sin War'
    • Reason: Original/non-VGM composition + in-game dialogue.
  31. OCR00133 - Super Castlevania IV 'Prologue Painmix'
    • Reason: SPC rip + drums.
  32. OCR00136 - Chrono Cross 'Lost in the Cross'
    • Reason: Quality issues.
  33. OCR00141 - Pilotwings 64 'Birdman (Clear Skies Mix)'
    • Reason: MIDI rip of previously arranged material with minor changes/additions.
  34. OCR00147 - Deadly Towers 'S&M Dungeon Tour'
    • Reason: MIDI rip.
  35. OCR00153 - Mario Paint 'Bug Bash BreakBeat'
    • Reason: SPC rip + beats.
  36. OCR00154 - Metroid 'Hemorrhoid'
    • Reason: MIDI rip of previously arranged material with minor changes/additions.
  37. OCR00164 - EarthBound 'Battle'
    • Reason: SPC rip. Too reliant on directly sampling the original.
  38. OCR00169 - Tales of Phantasia 'Freeze'
    • Reason: SPC rip. Slowed down, new instrumentation.
  39. OCR00193 - Dragon Warrior 'Reptile Jam'
    • Reason: Too reliant on sampled phrases/loops to provide the instrumentation.
  40. OCR00195 - Shadow Man 'Deadside Dance'
    • Reason: Too similar to the original.
  41. OCR00197 - Ninja Gaiden II 'Song of Chaos'
    • Reason: MIDI rip + beats.
  42. OCR00207 - Silent Hill 'Act 3 (Search for Cheryl)'
    • Reason: Not an arrangement, author admits to it being so. Samples first 8 seconds of source (among other parts), with original/non-VGM composition on top.
  43. OCR00213 - Out of This World 'Open Ending'
    • Reason: Too similar to the original.
  44. OCR00218 - Shenmue 'Matsuri Madness'
    • Reason: WAV rip + SFX, sped up.
  45. OCR00219 - Mega Man 2 'Crash the 70's Man'
    • Reason: Too reliant on sampled phrases/loops to provide the instrumentation.
  46. OCR00220 - Final Fantasy IX 'Melodies of Techno'
    • Reason: WAV rip + beats.
  47. OCR00223 - Super Mario 64 'Haunted Hell (IncuCujoKondoD.Bros. Mix)'
    • Reason: WAV rips + The Dust Brothers' "What Is Fight Club?" + Amon Tobin's (Cujo's) "Cruzer" + Vince Guaraldi Trio's "Christmas Time Is Here" + assorted sampled movie clips, author admits to it being so.
  48. OCR00230 - Castlevania: The Adventure 'CV2K'
    • Reason: Too reliant on directly sampling grade-up Akumajo Dracula Best 2 arranged album version of original.
  49. OCR00234 - Mega Man 2 'Crash Man Centuria'
    • Reason: NSF rip + drums.
  50. OCR00243 - Final Fantasy VI 'Wild West West'
    • Reason: SPC rip + drums/vocal loop.
  51. OCR00244 - Ristar 'Intension'
    • Reason: GYM rip + drums.
  52. OCR00249 - Xenogears 'Gathering Stars'
    • Reason: Too similar to the original.
  53. OCR00253 - Wizball 'Catelite Lives'
    • Reason: SID rip + drums/SFX.
  54. OCR00254 - Metal Gear 'Super Computer (System Malfunction)'
    • Reason: NSF rip + John Williams' 'Duel of the Fates'.
  55. OCR00259 - Anticipation 'Ice Cream Bear Shoe Horn'
    • Reason: NSF rip. Too reliant on directly sampling the original.
  56. OCR00265 - Excitebike 'Title Techno Phatulence'
    • Reason: Lacking in arrangement. Quality issues.
  57. OCR00266 - Sims '(Acid Techno Trip)'
    • Reason: Original/non-VGM composition + in-game voices.
  58. OCR00277 - Arkanoid 'c64 Vibe'
    • Reason: SID rip + drums.
  59. OCR00283 - Pop-Up '80s Mix'
    • Reason: Briefly added new writing, but too similar to the original.
  60. OCR00284 - R.C. Pro-Am 'Insomnic Intro'
    • Reason: NSF rip.
  61. OCR00288 - Final Fantasy V 'Fantastico Mambo Techno Disco de Chocobo'
    • Reason: Direct samples Los Mambos Panchos' 'Mambo de Chocobo' from Final Fantasy V: Mambo de Chocobo arranged album + bwomp-chicka/drums.
  62. OCR00290 - Kid Icarus 'Little Kids Can't Fly'
    • Reason: Quality issues.
  63. OCR00293 - Earthworm Jim 2 'Title Topsoil'
    • Reason: SPC rip + drums.
  64. OCR00298 - Chrono Trigger 'A Frog, A Sword, and a Spoony Bard'
    • Reason: Too reliant on sampled phrases/loops to provide the instrumentation.
  65. OCR00299 - Final Fantasy VII 'Cool Cat Sithe'
    • Reason: WAV rip + effects.
  66. OCR00321 - New Zealand Story 'Look at Kiwi Kiwi'
    • Reason: NSF rip + drums.
  67. OCR00333 - Doom II 'Monster Condo'
    • Reason: MIDI rip + atmospheric sounds.
  68. OCR00351 - Vectorman 2 'Floating Point Vectors'
    • Reason: GYM rips + sampled guitar/drums, SFX.
  69. OCR00359 - Final Fantasy Legend III 'Talon (Injury Mix)'
    • Reason: GBS rip, looped 2 1/2 times.
  70. OCR00367 - Black & White 'Clash of da Creatures'
    • Reason: WAV rip + drums.
  71. OCR00382 - DuckTales 'Duck Side of the Moon'
    • Reason: MIDI rip + Blue Öyster Cult's 'Don't Fear the Reaper' guitar riff. Quality issues.
  72. OCR00396 - Final Fantasy Legend II 'Injured Hero's Blood'
    • Reason: GBS rip. Too similar to the original.
  73. OCR00400 - Spy vs. Spy 'Happy Psy'
    • Reason: NSF rip + drums.
  74. OCR00435 - Revenge of Shinobi 'Steve's Freaky Bass'
    • Reason: GYM rip. Too reliant on directly sampling the original.
  75. OCR00441 - DuckTales 'Walking on the Moon'
    • Reason: Too similar to the original. Sped up verbatim melody + drums, minor additions.
  76. OCR00452 - Grandia 'Northern Beach of Ganbo'
    • Reason: Too similar to the original.
  77. OCR00500 - Blood Money 'Sky Surfer'
    • Reason: MOD rip. Too similar to the original.
  78. OCR00507 - Turrican II 'The Desert Remake'
    • Reason: MOD rip. Too similar to the original.
  79. OCR00540 - Blast Corps 'Faster'
    • Reason: MIDI rip of previously arranged material with minor changes/additions, author admits to it being so.
  80. OCR00548 - Wizards & Warriors 'Mighty Potion'
    • Reason: MIDI rip medley + several drum loops.
  81. OCR00554 - Sonic the Hedgehog 'Water Warning (U Can't Breathe 2 This)'
    • Reason: Too reliant on directly sampling (and cutting up) the original audio.
  82. OCR00566 - Mechwarrior 2: Mercenaries 'Mecharok'
    • Reason: WAV rip + strings/drums.
  83. OCR00579 - Sword of Vermilion 'MacSword'
    • Reason: GYM rips + drums.
  84. OCR00590 - Paperboy 'Evening Edition Jam'
    • Reason: Too reliant on sampled phrases/loops to provide the instrumentation.
  85. OCR00669 - Mario Kart 64 'Flag of Every Color'
    • Reason: Too similar to the original.
  86. OCR00695 - Super Mario World 'Vanilla Extract'
    • Reason: MIDI rip of previously arranged material with minor changes/additions.
  87. OCR00696 - Donkey Kong Country 'Apocalypse Oil'
    • Reason: Too similar to the original.
  88. OCR00737 - Mortal Kombat 'Komplete Kontrol'
    • Reason: Not a game music arrangement. The Mortal Kombat CD single (November 30, 1993) came out before the Sega CD game (May 26, 1994). Source tune isn't originally from the 1995 movie soundtrack (where it's most known), but is also not music originally created for the game.
  89. OCR00783 - Turbo OutRun 'Slam the Gas'
    • Reason: SID rip + drums.
  90. OCR00820 - Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past 'Fairy Acid'
    • Reason: SPC rip with creative processing and drums.
  91. OCR00870 - GoldenEye 007 'Symphonic Caverns'
    • Reason: Too similar to the original. Author requested removal.
  92. OCR00979 - Super Metroid 'Mellow Dramatic Metroid Medley'
    • Reason: SPC rips, author admits to it being so.
  93. OCR00997 - Super Ghouls 'N Ghosts 'Swimming in Zombie Guts'
    • Reason: SPC rip. Too similar to the original.

ReMixes Removed by Request

Beatdrop

  • OCR00461 - Final Fantasy VIII 'Man with the Trance Machine'
  • replaced by request with OCR00798 - Final Fantasy VIII 'Man with Another Trance Machine'

Compyfox

  • Final Fantasy Adventure 'Mission of Mana'

FFmusic Dj

  • Final Fantasy II 'Promised Land'
  • Final Fantasy VII 'Aeris Chasm'
  • Final Fantasy VIII 'Find Your Way'

Hornpipe2

  • OCR00073 - Donkey Kong 'Kennedy Hammer'
  • replaced by request with OCR00073 - Lotus II RECS 'Overdrive'

JD Harding

  • OCR00260 - Sonic 3D Blast 'Panic Puppet'
  • OCR00278 - Mega Man 3 'Electric Mix'
  • OCR00285 - F-Zero 'JD Mute City'
  • OCR00406 - Killer Instinct 'Reflex'
  • OCR00423 - Super Metroid 'Darkstar'
  • OCR00749 - Sonic 3D Blast 'Trippy Puppet Style'
  • OCR00794 - Chrono Trigger 'Daughter of Evil'
  • OCR00812 - Sonic the Hedgehog 3 'Snowy Caps'
  • OCR01059 - Super Castlevania IV 'Belmont Mix [2003]'

prozax

  • Blaster Master 'Rocket'
  • Blaster Master 'Through the Eyes of Tragedy'
  • Guardian Legend '8-bit Rox'
  • Half-Life 'Time to Choose'
  • Mario Kart 64 'Dream Racing'
  • NiGHTS into Dreams... 'Good NiGHT'
  • Radical Dreamers 'Intonation'
  • U.N. Squadron 'The Best of the Best'

Subliminal Labs

  • Castlevania 'subliminal'

virt

  • Adventure Island 'Higgins Goes to Miami'
  • Balloon Fight 'Ska Poppin'
  • Contra 'Contravirt'
  • Dr. Mario 'Funky Pills'
  • Faxanadu 'Funk Fusion'
  • ToeJam & Earl 'Wake Up!'
Retrieved from "https://ocremix.org./wiki/index.php?title=ReMix_Changelog&oldid=4616"

Promotion

Latest Albums

Latest ReMixes

Navigation